From the TYP356NE club members:
A 1955 Shine-down:
And a post-'57 changeover shine up light:
And I found this; a car VERY similar to what my older brother had when I was a kid and only added here because I like it:
But you know, I wouldn't get to hung up on shine up or shine down on a replica. I've seen plenty of things not even close to original that look OK. Like Bee-hives with a shine up, PLUS a 3-gauge dash rather than 2-gauge, VW dash knobs (not Porsche) and a centered hood handle (most of the pre-A's had the handle off-set by up to 1/4").
The bottom line? Don't sweat it......