Skip to main content

Question for those that may be mechanically inclined.  Is it possible for the engine/transmission to “ shift back” (come loose from their mount points and move backwards)?  

i experienced a never before encountered mechanical today that has me thinking I may need a mechanic with a lift to comfortably diagnose my problem.

I took my 2013 VS built speedy for the first longish + 50 mile ride of the season. As I was getting home driving up an a steady hill my engine rev up quickly ( without me stepping on the pedal, +4000rpm and would not come down when I removed my foot completely from the pedal… it held steady at ~+4000. …  I thought my throttle cable got stuck/ frayed in the tube and I quickly turned the key off and rolled to a stop. ( about 5-6 seconds transpired from rev up to me engaging the clutch and pulling the key).

- when I looked in the engine compartment I noticed the carbs where 3/4 opened, and again though the cable was frayed/stuck in the tube pulling the hex bar/ carbs to the open position.

- when I detached the cable from my CB hex bar the carb springs  quickly pulled back to  the idle stopper screws- to the closed position. All was good.

- thinking it was a bad cable that needed replacement, but before pulling it (I had a spare in the car), I wanted to test it to see how hard it it was stuck in the ltube… and to my surprise it moved freely inside the tube.  ( pulling and pushing from the pedal and cable side  i encountered no resistance).

- so I decided to reconnect the same cable to the carb linkage… and noticed the cable/screw connection point to the hex bar was now about 1cm further down the cable—- meaning, where before I had 5 cm of extra length in the cable I now only had 4cm with the hexbar/carbs in the closed idle only position- the carb spring stopper fully resting on the idle screws.

- I started the car,  car idled perfectly and I proceeded to drive home after a little static testing of the gas pedal- cautiously.. . About a 4 mile flat side roads drive…everything ran smoothly...the pedal was as smooth as before, no cable/pedal resistance…. Engine ran and sounded perfect.   Throttle was just as smooth as before… I could run the car through all the gears and up to 4300rpm  without issue. … drove home and could not stop thinking- WHAT would make me need 1cm extra of  throttle cable? Cables don’t shrink!.

- so I took the car back out for a test to drive and decided to take on some hills.   No issues driving up, but driving down long hills, where I let the engine do some of the braking- when I stepped on the gas I would hear some knocking, and noticed my shifter move forward back in a new unexpected way-  triggered by me stepping on the gas while driving down hill, or stepping off the glass and letting the engine do some of the braking.   Pulled over and checked the shift coupler… noticed when in 1st and 3rd the shift coupler made contact with the pan/ frame. I felt this contact in the shifter, See pics:

car in 2nd looks ok:

551C9B9C-21EC-4B1C-9E54-7BFCC6ACEF7D

car in 1st. Coupler makes contact with the rear of the frame.  Coupler looks ok… but why would it suddenly make contact with the frame.  When I put the car in first I definitely feel the contact being made in my shifter,

6A21D1CE-5734-4E29-85DB-06B1A492599A

now with two symptoms—- having added 1 cm to my throttle cable length, and now seeing the shift coupler has slid back enough to now  make contact with the pan when in 1st and 3rd gear.….  brings me back to my question: what would cause my engine/trani to shift back in my car?

unfortunately I don’t have access to a lift to easily inspect the underpinings, nor the expertese… any thoughts?    Should I be looking for rotted out polyurethane engine or transmission mounts ( do these cars even have those),  or loose engine/transmission mount bolts, or could my pan have experienced some sort of dry rot failure,

no leaks, no other symptoms..l just the knocking of the shifter/coupler when doing down hill and feathering the gas ( after having allowed the engine to do some of the downhill braking), and the longer cable.

ANY thoughts would be appreciated.…. Other than this, car runs great!!!!!… today I even took the hard top off for the season.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 551C9B9C-21EC-4B1C-9E54-7BFCC6ACEF7D
  • 6A21D1CE-5734-4E29-85DB-06B1A492599A
Last edited by Lfepardo
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

@Lfepardo asked: "Should I be looking for rotted out polyurethane engine or transmission mounts ( do these cars even have those),  or loose engine/transmission mount bolts, or could my pan have experienced some sort of dry rot failure?"

Yes, you should, but I doubt dry-rot failure.

There are three engine/transaxle mount points on your car.  There is one at the front of the transaxle nose cone, right behind the frame where your shift coupler is hitting the frame.  It is a piece of metal with a PVC cushion glued to it.  The bad ones have red urethane cushions that get brittle, break apart and fail.  The good ones are made of black rubber (stock VW or HD VW) or grey vinyl and made by Rhino mounts.  Yours has probably fatigued and separated, allowing the engine/transaxle to move rearward as a unit.

The other two mounting points are right where the engine mates to the transaxle at the bellhousing.  There is a mount at the bottom on each side.  They can be made of rubber  or Urethane.  Same as before, the good ones are rubber VW or gray vinyl from Rhino.  The bad ones are made of red urethane.

A decent mechanic can replace all three mounts more-or-less easily.  You mark and disconnect the shift coupler, remove the rear heat shields (he may not need to do this), disconnect the clutch cable, put a rolling floor jack under the engine/transaxle and move it back a couple/three inches to give clearance to get the old mounts out and new ones in.  Once swapped, bolt everything back together, re-connect the clutch and throttle cables and re-install the heat shields and you're done.   I've done this on a VW sedan in an afternoon.  A Speedster should be similar.

Last edited by Gordon Nichols

Well, I will have to look at the bright side… it’s the first time since I had the car built (2013) that the engine will be coming out.   Good opportunity to finally install the CB- Fast Fab truss bar  and Light Pedal- Extra Long Clutch Arm  (pictured below) that I have been waiting for the engine to come out to be installed ( since 2020 ;-)).  —- to have someone else do it since my garage is small and I hate crawling under the car for anything other than the annual oil/filter, and gas line filter change.

only wished I could be doing this w/the old timer mechanic I have been working with last 10 years… since engines/transmissions was his thing and he has used every maintenance  opportunity to teach me how to do things myself…. But I guess at 85 it’s fair he decided  enter his second retirement & to stop wrenching on other peoples cars after +65yrs.  He truly is the classic VW/Porsche engine whisperer… the guy northwest shops called when they were stumped and could not diagnose a problem.

thank you again for all your help.

D949B920-41E2-4286-AA78-909F5CC855A8

Attachments

Images (1)
  • D949B920-41E2-4286-AA78-909F5CC855A8
Last edited by Lfepardo

While you're at it, check the ginormous bolts on the ends of your frame horns. They hold the whole cradle on which your rear engine mounts mount.

They never back out. But if they ever did, and if the front mount were also broken (which it absolutely would be pretty soon!), they would allow your engine to slide back and forth a little.

Last edited by edsnova

Thank-you all for your guidance.   Just heard from the shop- turns out:

- failed forward transsmision mount.  Turns out VS ( Hawaian Gardens)  used a non VW mount, - not a generic or performance part--- but a home made mount-   urgh!- I'm the original owner, so it came like this from VS.

- the two 27mm engine mount bolts were loose (mechanic was able to back both out by hand once the engine was supported by a jack).

- on the lift engine/tran could be shifted /moved 1cm fwd/back.

-fortunatelly no rust/cracls on the horns/pan.

... so engine is out, all transmission mounts will be replaced with German VW mounts (correct parts for the year pan).. the truss bar and longer clutch arm will be installed, and fuel filters replaced with flesh metal Napa Gold.

Not a pleasant early spring surprise, but... after 13 yrs-  no serious damage, and an opportunity to replace bad parts and upgrade a few bits I had been storing for such a time as the engine coming out.   And I get to test drive the new mechanic/shop ( and hets to test drive me as a customer) my recently retired mechanic recommended.  Only sad bit is this new shop is not open to teach me- use me as an extra set of hands- with my repairs,

With a little luck I get the car back on Friday and can get back to driving it daily now that the sun is out.

Thank you again.

Last edited by Lfepardo

That's great news. Understandable on not letting you in the shop because of liability issues. maybe as you to become more acquainted those rules may become a bit more relaxed. That may have been a bit too much to be expected on the first meeting. Hope it all works out and you're up and running as expected on Friday. Just in time for the weekend.

Status, picked up car today and got in a 100mile loop to test things out,,,, and WOW!  What a difference having solid transmission mounts makes ;-)

Also, for anyone who ever wanted a softer feeling  clutch, with a little bigger engagement area ( vs that on-off typical feeling) I would highly recommend  the long clutch arm swap upgrade.

I’m sure most know about this- but figured I would share what little I know about this simple upgrade:

1B8BBABE-F130-4ADF-ADDE-D8E000B8A897

- A 72 or earlier transmission will probably have the short 73mm arm, (#1)… my VS did… and in traffic and after long drives my leg would feel a bit tired because of the “ vintage design clutch”, specially after my 3 COVID time frame knee surgeries,   By switching to the 100mm long arm (#2) you will reduce your clutch pedal effort by almost 40%. ( back of the envelope force calculation.… and WOW was the change noticeable today… felt like driving with a modern clutch in traffic.

- A 73 to 75 transmission will likely  have the 90mm arm (#4). The upgrade for that is the 100mm arm (#5). Although not as dramatic as the early clutch arm upgrade, it reduces pedal effort by ~11%. This is definitely noticeable.

#1-3 fit  a16mm diameter clutch arm shaft ( quick test is to hold a dime to the shaft.. if it’s the same size, presto! You have an early clutch arm shaft).   #4-5 fit a 20mm shaft, I believe.

The 100mm longer arms are not easy to come by,  but they do pop up on the Samba, Wagen Werks ( not sure they are still open), and I believe Cip1 sometimes  stocks them.  I got mine from Bruce some time ago in Vancouver.

I’m really happy with this update.

wishing everyone a great weekend.

cheers,

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1B8BBABE-F130-4ADF-ADDE-D8E000B8A897
Last edited by Lfepardo

#3 is Al’s clutch arm, right?



FWIW, I went the other way. I had a long arm and it was an exaggerated angle when I went to a hydraulic clutch, so I put a short one on it. I didn’t really notice any increase in effort. But I have a Spyder, and the hydro clutch eliminated the weird Rube Goldberg 180° pulley contraption that my car came with.

Last edited by dlearl476

Yeah, and you probably got a 5/8" master and a 7/8" or 3/4" slave, which is the hydraulic equivalent of a longer clutch arm. The clutch effort is VERY light on my car, especially with the Sachs HD clutch instead of the Kennedy.

Weddle also makes a 16mm clutch cross shaft for a later style throwout bearing. They also stock various bushings to fit the trans case. They can get you parts to make just about any combo work. They even sell an adapter sleeve that allows later style clutches to work with early 6v transmissions.

Last edited by DannyP

Now I'm incentivized to get back out in the shop and get my engine and new clutch back in.  I was making great progress, but ran into troubles when re-assembling the fan shroud to the engine and had to take a couple of steps back.  😠

So I walked away for a couple of days to attend my wife's college reunion and should be back in the shop, today.

I also want to make up a cradle for my floor jack to hold the engine better, to make putting it back in the car easier.

Now I'm incentivized to get back out in the shop and get my engine and new clutch back in.  I was making great progress, but ran into troubles when re-assembling the fan shroud to the engine and had to take a couple of steps back.  😠

So I walked away for a couple of days to attend my wife's college reunion and should be back in the shop, today.

I also want to make up a cradle for my floor jack to hold the engine better, to make putting it back in the car easier.

I feel your pain. Just when it started to get warm enough to work in my storage unit, my back went south and I got a case of Vertigo. (BPPV). I’ve been virtually disabled for 2.5 months. Meanwhile, my broken Spyder sits gathering dust.

I Haven’t touched it except to put the battery tender on it since I caught Covid the day I broke it.

Last edited by dlearl476
Post Content
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×