Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

 The starter can be taken apart a repaired.  For $75 many just go with a mass volume rebuilt one.  It could be that current to the starter is not sufficient due to dirty/corroded wires or even just a dirty failing solenoid.  Seems most "rebuilt" starters are just repaired (only the failing part) , painted and resold. If it is not addressed  starter quickly, the starter gear gets ground up --- or worse case grinds up the gear on the flywheel then engine has to be removed and flywheel replaced 

http://forums.vwvortex.com/showthread.php?2359900

90% for sure it's a starter issue, check to see if you can snug it first but you'll probably  need to remove it  checking the flywheel teeth . The good news is you can buy a good rebuilt from Auto Zone and Advance Auto Parts for just $45.99 w/ $16 core charge !  DO get the starter for an Auto Stick VW Beetle (it's not in their store but 1-2 day from their Whse.) It's interchangeable with the stick shift starter. It has a more torque and has the bushing built into a nose cone on the starter.......That's all I use.   " Drclock"

Last edited by Alan Merklin

OEM ones seemed to have lasted 20+ years or so.  A year is not normal at all.  If you engine is higher HP it probably takes more to turn it over - plus it could generate more heat that designed for too.  The quality of many rebuilt starters, generators, and alternators --- even new Chinese one is questionable.  I'd clean all your connections (start and battery plus grounds) - add dielectric grease to connections then see if that fixes it - if not remove starter and see if you can find obvious issue.  You might be able to find an old school place that can test it but if you can find the AT starter inexpensive with a lifetime warranty I'd do that.  Just remember that lifetime is not really lifetime - so keep the receipt.

"I've put 11,000 km on the car this year.  Is this normal wear and tear for a starter?"

Not with the original VW ones, but the Chinese reproductions are junk (as you now know!)  The Originals often lasted 100,000 miles, the Chinese ones maybe a quarter of that.

You could get the one you have rebuilt (usually around $75) if there is an automobile electrical/starter repair shop nearby, or you could go the VW route at Bug City <that's their link) but the originals will be $100 for a tested, used Auto-Stick and over $200 for a New Old Stock one.  Used and new regular VW starters are each about half that money, respectively.

Days have their ups and downs. The folks at Pierside Parts are experts, that impart great advice. That was the highpoint of the day. I bought the IMI high torque starter. If I ever upgrade the 1600cc, I won't be replacing the starter. 

I attached a picture of the proper orientation. If you do it the wrong way, you'll come nigh to pulling a spleen. So, after putting it in wrong, then installing it correctly, I discovered two things : 1) part of the wiring that attaches to the starter solenoid had fallen in the gap between the starter and the fly wheel; and 2) another wire that attaches to the starter solenoid is not long enough to reach the post. 

This is where I give up. 

The wiring floats above the drive train and below the back seat. So how do you access it?  The wire that got pinched is exposed and compromised. 

Anyone know a mechanic in the Irvine / Lake Forest area?

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMI starter in correct alignment: IMI starter in correct alignment
  • Old versus new
Last edited by Large Dachshund

VS packed my speedster with a regular bolt on the original!  You're right that the "V" that would trap the head of the Daddy bolt is not available on the IMI. @ALB, it's worth buying the IMI based on the weight alone. I'll say one more thing about pulling the starter. If you have T-Rex arms, this job will be a pain. There's quite a bit of torquing and pulling and pushing at arms length!

I'm still getting a delay and, when the starter fires, it does sound like your drill powering up, which is expected. I'm going under tomorrow to splice the frayed section. I'm thinking the electricity is getting impeded on that wire. 

One last thing. This point is purely speculative. I drove 6,000 miles on a brand new starter. Glenn at Pierside Parts pointed out that the original starter had way too much wobble in the rotation. This was caused by the bushing wearing away in the block. Or, maybe the bushing was never installed in the first place!

Last edited by Large Dachshund

Add Reply

Post Content
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×